Recent Five Star Reviews from Yelp and Google

caret-down caret-up caret-left caret-right
Sabrina Salazar September 8, 2018

So consistent in quality and service!

Maria Carrion-Kozak September 7, 2018

LOVE their Sicilian pizza. We have ordered three times so far in the last 2 months. The pizzas we have ordered (a variety of them) have been delicious. We ask for extra crispy crust and they deliver. When the pizzas get to our house, they are still hot!!!

Ronnica Fatt September 1, 2018
I can't believe that I have lived in Belmar 4 years before I tried Johnny's pizza! My husband and I now go to Johnny's when we want to eat out. Good prices and even better food...served quickly with great service!
John Green August 23, 2018
Great prices to match the excellent service and food. Been coming here for years and never had a bad experience.
Stephanie Marston August 14, 2018
If you like fresh pizza, this is the place!!
Tricia Hodge August 13, 2018
Great pizza and service
Kaylee Sanchez August 13, 2018
They're always good.
Frances B. August 12, 2018
Fast, friendly, and tasty!
Gregory D. August 5, 2018
What a treat. I asked a friend what the best pizza place was on the west side of town and she told me Johnny's was the place to go. I was not disappointed. Perfectly cooked. Great service, Bathrooms were spotless. I believe if the bathrooms are clean so is the rest of the restaurant. I live in Aurora and will drive 40 minutes to enjoy another pizza from Johnny's.  My friend told me not to forget to order some garlic knots. I forgot. I will be back.
Andria Thomas July 14, 2018
This place is great! I've been here a few times, staff is friendly, food is amazing and quick!
Patricia Gonzales July 12, 2018
Love Johnny's been going there for almost 12 years never have had bad service or bad pizza awesome place thanks Johnny!
Jan E. July 11, 2018
Delicious! Pizzas are all set up to just add your toppings and throw it in the oven to finish baking. Quick and delicious!
Mrs. Penguin July 10, 2018
The food here is great and everyone is very helpful and friendly
Travis Hellwig July 10, 2018
Best pizza in the area if you dont like a lot of crust and love quality toppings and flavor. Highly recommend the Dads Favorite!
Elizabeth C. July 3, 2018
We go here all the time. Pizza, meatball parm sandwich, chicken parm dinner. Always consistent and never disappoints!
T. C. June 21, 2018
Best pizza delivery I've ever had, right in my new neighborhood! Really good pizza with quality toppings and crust, I love it! Kind of funny to be really excited about a great place like this, but they have a ton of options beyond their excellent pizza and its delivery too! I find myself ordering every week or two. Keep it up guys!
Jack W. June 21, 2018
The service has improved vastly over the past year and the pizza is always consistent and top-notch.  Our favorite pizza in the area!
Rostelia Adams June 14, 2018
Fantastic service and pizza every time I've gone.
Micaela Thomas June 10, 2018
Amazing food and service. Will definitely go back.
Jason R R. May 25, 2018
I've ordered delivery from this place a few times. They always get here fast like under 30 mins from the moment I place my order online. I can't complain about anything, the pizza is excellent and the garlic knots are like crack. Their prices are fair too, I strongly recommend this place it's my number one choice for delivery in Lakewood.
Mr. M. May 23, 2018
Johnny's is great! It's our favorite local pizza joint. I just wish they would give me some free za...haha! Glad that they remodeled after the nasty hail storm.
Kaylyn E. May 19, 2018
This is my favorite pizza place; hands down. I found out about it because they are generous donors to the After School Program that Lakewood offers, where I was previously employed. They were always great with the kids and gave us more than we needed.  This poured over into my personal life, and someone who supports the kids and local programs is someone who automatically has my heart. Their pizza is AMAZING, and their calzones are to die for! I am so thrilled they're back open after the hailpocolypse.
Laura C. April 18, 2018

Great pizza! We got it delivered through a third party and it was fresh and hot! We will definitely be back.

Felix J. March 30, 2018
Whoa probably the BEST pizza in colorado was suspect with the "NY Pizza" name since I'm from NYC and love pizza but let me tell you there pizza was great added spinach and they did there thing when I visit the city again I'll visit this place again and try some of there other dishes KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK!! And super Cheap!! Can't be beat...
Zsanae M. March 16, 2018
Amazing service, amazing food! This is our go to place when we are craving pizza or pasta. Well worth it every time and customer service is always above and beyond.
P and A February 22, 2018
Awesome pizza - properly New York style (as close as you can get) and one of us grew up in Manhattan! This definitely hits the spot. Please extend delivery area!
Rebeka M. January 20, 2018
I ordered the three cheese calzone with spinach! Yum. Perfect mix of cheeses and the sauce OMG. The sauce actually has flavor. Most places I go the sauce is terrible BUT NOT HERE! It has small chunks of tomato and is seasoned perfectly to my taste- hehe and I'm Italian ;). I recommend stopping by here at least once in your life. The price was good too. 8 bucks for the calzone.